FORMAT COMPARISON
JSON vs YAML: Data Types and Configuration Choices
Start with the format required by the receiving application. Compare syntax, typed values and configuration needs using two original fixtures with matching data.
Key differences
| Property | JSON | YAML |
|---|---|---|
| MIME type | application/json | application/yaml |
| Encoding | UTF-8 for exchange between open systems | UTF-8 / UTF-16 / UTF-32 input (YAML 1.2); UTF-8 recommended for output |
| Container | Not applicable | Not reviewed |
| Compression / coding | Not inherent to the format | Not reviewed |
| Signature | No registered magic number | No registered magic number |
Unavailable catalog facts remain marked “Not reviewed” instead of being guessed.
Choose by workflow
Choose JSON when
The receiving API or parser requires JSON. Use its defined object, array and scalar syntax.
Choose YAML when
The configuration consumer requires YAML and the team benefits from comments and block-style mappings or sequences.
Verify before choosing
Agree on the YAML version and schema. Parse the document and check value types, duplicate keys and the consumer’s validation rules.
Compare two files with the same parsed values
Download the JSON and YAML fixtures. Both contain active=true, code="00123", and two nested items. YAML adds a comment; the parsed data is identical under the reviewed YAML 1.2 core-schema test.
Common use cases
- JSON: structured data exchanged with a JSON consumer.
- YAML: configuration read by a specified YAML implementation.
Compatibility and workflow
Keep numeric-looking identifiers quoted when they are strings. Recheck types after conversion; changing the filename does not convert syntax.
Limitations to check
Comments and YAML-specific features need an explicit conversion policy. A successful parse is separate from satisfying the application schema.